From Time Immemorial – The Joan Peters Project Introduction


Peters

In George Orwell’s dystopia, written during WWII he imagines a totalitarian future where history is inverted and language is perverted. This is what we now mean by “politically correct speech.” And so we must draw inspiration from someone, who in 1984, took on the false and politically correct narrative that Israel is an occupier of Arab land where Arabs have supposedly lived in the land of Israel, since “time immemorial.”

In 1984, a successful and well-known female American journalist, who had specialized in reporting the Israeli-Arab conflict, published a book called From Time Immemorial: The Origins of the Arab-Jewish Conflict over Palestine. The journalist in question was Joan Peters, (who recently passed away). Peters had begun her career in the Middle East as a sympathizer with the Arabs of Palestine. However, the more she learned, the more she began to question the dominant anti-Israeli narrative that she had absorbed in the Arab World and she began to change her opinion. This caused her to become her own historian and to delve into the British archives for the period of the Mandate for Palestine, from 1922 to 1948.

Her most profound discovery was that the majority of the Arabs living both west and east of the Jordan River come from outside that area, from what is now Eastern Turkey, Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Egypt and as far away as North Africa. One of her key sources was a PhD in anthropology who, when doing studies of marriage and kinship ties among Arab Israelis, discovered that a great preponderance of the Arab clans west of the Jordan had extraterritorial origins.

Delving into the British archives, Peters put together a thesis that strongly argued that despite the fact that the Balfour Declaration and the Mandate for Palestine were designed to reconstitute an independent Jewish homeland in Palestine through immigration of Jews from all of the world, instead, British administrators on the ground adopted an anti-Jewish and anti-Zionist approach to the Mandate and did everything possible to facilitate the illegal immigration of Arabs from surrounding countries.

Peters’ central thesis flew in the face of the anti-Zionists, who claim that the Arabs of Palestine had been there for centuries, that is to say “from time immemorial,” which is the intentionally ironic title of her book. For a short period of time, the Likud and conservatives around the world used her book to demonstrate that most Palestinians were not indigenous to the land of Israel. However, soon afterwards some Israeli scholars, supported by Noam Chomsky himself, smeared Peters, charging that her research was superficial and that her core demographic conclusions were wrong.

Recent academic research on the demography of the land of Israel during the last 150 years, suggest that Peters was not wrong, and that the exponential increase of Arabs into the area of the Mandate for Palestine from 1922 to 1948, was largely due to British encouragement and the fact that the incoming Jewish Zionists were creating a dynamic economy which attracted labour from surrounding countries, whose economies were stagnant.

In 1974, I volunteered as an agricultural laborer on a left wing kibbutz in Israel. I was astounded to find out that the neighbouring Arab villagers had moved there from Egypt, lock stock and barrel in 1922. At that time, I did not have sufficient historical understanding that I subsequently gained from reading Peters’ book. It is now clear that this village was part of a wider movement of Arabs from the wider Near East into the land of Israel, where they were treated better than their traditional Arab landlords, given a reasonable wage and had their medical issues taken care of, suggesting ironically, that in many respects the Arabs of Palestine have gained a higher quality of life; better than that of the Jewish Israelis who’ve had to fight for it and protect it.

When you read Peters’ book you will find many other chapters that make you realize that Israel and its people are there “by right not by might.” One chapter focuses on personal recollections of Jews from Arab countries who were expelled by their governments and came to Israel. In the lands of their birth, their money and property was confiscated and they very often suffered the violence of pogroms before they were allowed by the various Arab dictators to join the new state of Israel, the homeland of the Jewish people.

Recent scholarship suggests that these recollections are classic examples of dhimmitude. Dhimmitude refers to the second class treatment of the Jewish and Christian minorities under Shariah law creating a fearful personality that is transformed only when the children of these people are born in a free country, such as Israel or any of the other English speaking democracies.

Despite the fact that the data and arguments of Joan Peters’ book are even stronger today, given recent scholarship, her work is not widely read, certainly not by the Rabbis of the Jewish community. Her book is rarely quoted by Zionists. Many conservative friends of Israel are not aware of it. It is time for its resurrection.

2017 marked the 100th anniversary of the Balfour declaration, which became the basis for the Mandate for Palestine in 1922, which, according to international law, is still valid and which gave Israel land rights west of the Jordan until the sea. We have engaged a group of volunteers to summarize each of the 18 chapters of Joan Peters book. We will then contact like-minded scholars and academics both inside and outside of Israel to update the data of each of the 18 chapters. We will then write an updated summary of each chapter and the latest bibliography which supports it and post it on the Internet.

We will then engage a series of translators who will translate this project into Hebrew, Arabic, Turkish, Urdu, Hindi, French, Italian and Spanish. These will then be posted on the Internet. It is our hope that Joan Peters’ book and the updated arguments of the book, will share with the public the true story of Israel and its relation to the Arab communities that surround it, and unfortunately still threaten its existence.

This project is an effort of enlightened volunteers and its follow-up will include lesson plans and podcasts that could become the basis of curriculum in both secular and Jewish schools. We unfortunately live in a time where untruth has become the norm. Israel is portrayed as a white, colonial, apartheid regime of people from Europe who oppress so-called indigenous Arabs. Nothing could be further from the truth. The Jews are the indigenous people of the land of Israel. Joan Peters’ book shows that this is indeed the case and that the Arabs are newcomers.

We believe that there will be very little progress towards reconciliation in the Middle East until people in the Muslim world have access to this material, so that they can then digest the true history of the conflict between Israel and its Muslim neighbours.

This is a project which demonstrates that there can be no peace without the truth. George Orwell, had he been alive today would have given us his blessing.

First published in Behind the News.

71,261 Comments

  1. King Johnnie Kash VIP Casino is a trusted and reliable name in online gaming since 2010 – being one of the top 10 most visited sites and has over 1 million registered users. They offer player with one click in an instant and safe bankrolls for your favourite game, with a lot of fun at no cost. Join now and become an owner of King Johnnie Kash VIP Casino to enjoy all the advantages!
    cash kings betting

  2. Hello, I think your blog might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your website in Chrome, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other than that, awesome blog!

  3. Я извиняюсь, но, по-моему, Вы не правы. Могу отстоять свою позицию. Пишите мне в PM, обсудим.
    ремонт фотоаппарата nikon d200, d300, d600, d700, d800 не всегда просматривает карту памяти, ремонт фотоаппаратов в москве восстановление карт ридера.

  4. Nude massage : massage service nude massage
    We adamantly refused the idea at first but Jonas was the one that convinced us it was right. Add eliminated foods back into your diet, one at a time, every four days. Others believe that foods from the nightshade family, such as tomatoes, potatoes, and peppers, aggravate their condition, although others don’t notice any connection. If you think certain foods play a role in your arthritis symptoms, it is important to put them to the test. Ample amounts of tissue-building minerals in your daily diet will keep bones healthy and may help prevent bone spurs, a common complication of arthritis. This painful and debilitating joint disease is usually either classified as osteoarthritis (OA) or rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Horsetail’s cornucopia of minerals, including silicon, may nourish joint cartilage. For a more contemporary twist on Halloween, give a nod to NASCAR and continue to the next page to outfit your little Dale or Danica in full racing style — including a customized car to trick-or-treat in! Daily Mail. “How a little too much cleavage can cost you a job interview.” Sept. It took 5 months to build at a cost of $1 million and is equipped with waterfalls, fountains and a 15-foot (4.5-meter) waterslide.
    Some employers want to get the basics out of the way quickly. You might also want to consult your physician before undergoing reflexology. They don’t want to waste anyone’s time. People will tell you that you are wasting your time. The job interview is your time to shine. Try to use appropriate terminology in the interview. Although coconut oil is recommended by some people for ringworm, the treatment you use will depend on its location on your body and how serious it is, per the CDC. Reducing muscle tension will result to both physical and mental relaxation because it reduces the negative health effects of chronic stress, enabling the body to heal and relax. This treatment improves posture, relaxation, and releases muscle tension and stress. This gives you a variety of treatment options at the touch of a button. Asking about perks in the wrong way could prove disastrous. Don’t clam up. Everyone has varying degrees of shyness, but you need to talk about your employment experiences concisely and in an interesting way. The key is to learn from both experiences.
    Nightshades for several months. As a result, the interviewee starts talking because they figure there’s something wrong with the answer they have just given. Some interviews have been painful and disastrous. These can help him or her determine if you have a kidney problem. It can also help you in court should that situation arise. Women who wear tight tops that accentuate their cleavage to a job interview can kiss the job goodbye, according to a survey. A job interview is not a casual conversation between friends in bar. Conversely, don’t ramble, even when there’s a pause in the conversation. Even if your interviewer swears, don’t get comfortable and swear, too. Rubbing your nose, even if it itches, could mean you’re dishonest. If the interviewer gives you the silent treatment after you answered a question, shut your pie hole and show confidence in your previous answer. Just give enough detail to answer the question.
    Dandruff while bringing out the natural oils in the dog’s fur. Move out of his space. It is important to get the maximum out of each massage session that you get. The CBD used in our massage is sourced from Colorado, Organic and THC free. Undercover officers offered masseuses money in exchange for sexual acts at a West 103rd Street massage parlor. Instead, it is a highly formal exchange where profanity is verboten. U.S. News. World Report. S. News. World Report. To borrow from John Lennon, you may say I’m a dreamer, but I’m not the only one, and I write for the dreamers of the world. In some instances, however, heat may aggravate a joint that’s already “hot” from inflammation, as is sometimes the case with rheumatoid arthritis. What most people don’t realize, however, is that there are natural herbal remedies that help relieve the pain of arthritis associated with getting older. A deficiency of essential mineralsmay be one of the causes of arthritis. What was one drop rule?

  5. На сайте https://kak-pochemy.ru/ вы сможете получить ответы на многочисленные вопросы. К примеру, вы узнаете о том, какие корма для кошек считаются самыми качественными и созданы без усилителей вкуса, химикатов, узнаете о том, какие производители диванов самые надежные. На портале представлены различные рейтинги, которые помогут определиться с покупкой. Вместе с тем, получите ответ на вопрос, который касается лучших машин до определенной суммы. Хотите отказаться от сахара, но не знаете, как это сделать? Тогда скорей воспользуйтесь советами, представленными на портале.

  6. WINDOW REPLACEMENT & INTRODUCTION IN MASSACHUSETTS
    People in Boston, MA are hip of the distinction of the windows in their houses window replacement cost calculator . They cognizant of that without je sais quoi windows not only purposefulness it be brutal with a view them to appeal to buyers, but also they disposition not catch the haven from cold, moisture and conclude that they desire. Windows are a given of the most momentous elements of a house.

  7. Dismantling intimate window replacement wooden windows with double-glazed windows or ductile structures can be done in two ways. The maiden one can be called fastidious, as the edging of the dismantled window intention not be damaged, and therefore it will discover a modishwindow replacement Aspectmontage handling, for lesson, in the countryside. The aide-de-camp method of dismantling is more straightforward, but it commitment be impossible to have recourse to the window unit, as the skeleton in the removal process will be sawn into dissimilar parts. The marred approach is normal to dismantle rather worn out windows window companies in me that are not suitable quest of further use.

  8. King Johnnie Kash VIP Casino presents you with a beautiful and exciting gaming experience. Every casino era is full of great excitement, but we are striving to make our time at the casino all the more memorable by giving you all new incentives and rewards.
    johnykash casino

Leave a Reply to llaves motos Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

22 − = 12